All of my Italian cookies are homemade ("Pasticcini Casalinghi”) and no two cookies are the exact same size or weight. There are approximately 18 - 25 cookies per pound. If you don't see your favorite cookie listed, please be sure to inquire if it can be made for you!
For those looking for sugar-free, gluten-free, macrobiotic, organic and even vegan, you will be happy to know that I have begun
to create a small line that are truly delicious! Please look for *****Notation in the product description.
Please note that all prices are for direct pick-up and do not include shipping or delivery charges. In order to have your cookies delivered locally, please note that there will be a minimum $20.00 delivery charge. Shipping is additional and is calculated at check-out.
Specialty Assortment Cookie Trays(**You can choose up to 3 types of cookies to be included on your tray -- however, Annabelle always tries to accommodate client selections as much as possible no matter the tray size and will try to include the variety that would be enjoyed the most! )
Cookie trays larger than three pounds will be priced individually by Annabelle.
For all cookie trays with Venetian Layer Cookies, Sposini, Lemon Biscottini, primarily Almond Macaroons, or Annabelle's Signature Coconut Macaroons, an additional $2.00 charge does apply. For Custom Tray orders containing "only" particular types of cookies, an additional fee will apply.
DUE TO WEBSITE ISSUES, SHIPPING MAY NOT BE INCLUDED WHEN YOU CHECK OUT AND MAY HAVE TO BE INVOICED SEPARATELY AND WILL NEED TO BE PAID PRIOR TO YOUR ORDER BEING SHIPPED!
1 lb. Assorted Regular Italian Cookie Tray (18-24 Cookies)
One delicious pound of a variety of Annabelle's Italian Cookies, including Cappuccino Cookies, Coconut-Lemon Bliss, Iced Italian Anisette, Verdacchio (Pistachio-Cherry), and Wedding Butter Cookies! Special pricing does apply if you wish to order only a particular kind of cookie.
Please note that Annabelle does reserve the right to substitute a type of Cookie of equal or greater value during peak seasons and when large events are occurring. In making substitutions, Annabelle takes great care and consideration in her selection in order to ensure that the substitute will meet or exceed the customer's expectations.
1 lb. Assorted Premium Italian Cookie Tray (18-24 cookies)
One delicious pound of a variety of Annabelle's Italian Cookies, including Almond Macaroons, Amaretto Cookies, Cucidati, Lemon Biscottini, , and Sposini.
Please note that Annabelle does reserve the right to substitute a Premium Cookie not named here during peak seasons and when large events are occurring. In making substitutions, Annabelle takes great care and consideration in her selection in order to ensure that the substitute will meet or exceed the customer's expectations.
1 lb. "Annabelle's Choice" Mixed Assorted Tray that consists of a few selections of both Regular and Premium Italian Cookies, Italian-American Cookies, and other non-listed cookies that have been freshly baked at the time of ordering from our bakery.
1 lb. Assorted American Cookie Tray that consists of Chocolate Chip, Italian-American Butter, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter, and Strawberry Chocolate Chip.
**3 Lbs. Assorted Italian Cookie Tray (54-66 Cookies)
Three delicious pounds of a variety of Annabelle's Italian Cookies, including Macaroons, Anisette Cookies, Butter Cookies, Cucidati, Lemon-Coconut Bliss Cookies, and more! When ordering the three-pound tray, you can select up to three different kinds of cookies to be included on your tray! Special pricing does apply if you wish to order only particular kinds of cookies.
Almond Macaroons ("Amaretti")
The Italian Almond Macaroon/Amaretti has a long history in Italian culture and truly is a very "traditional Italian" cookie. Annabelle's Italian Almond Macaroons (a/k/a Amaretti cookies) are made from only the finest almond paste. These soft and chewy Italian cookies are truly a cookie Nonna would be proud to call her own!
Pictured here topped with Almond Slices and Cherry Halves, as well as Cherry Macaroons and Chocolate Chip Macaroons. "Pignoli" (Macaroons with Pine Nuts) are not pictured.
Please specify which kind of macaroon you wish to receive under the PayPal Tab Once signed in or complete a Contact form and send Annabelle a note as to your preference. If no preference is chosen, then it is agreed that Annabelle will make an appropriate selection for you.
Please Note, if ordering Pignoli's Cookies, due to the increased cost of pine nuts, an additional $8 will be billed to you prior to shipping.
Thank you!
*****Can be made 100% Gluten-Free - Just request that they are!
Minimum Order - 1lb (approx. 18-20)
Almond-Filled Crescent Cookies ("Mezzelune di Mandorla")
Filled with Annabelle's special blended Almond-paste, this cookie is sure to take you back in time! Iced with Nana's powder-sugar icing, these almond-filled crescent cookies are sure to be gobbled up in no time!
8 oz. Minimum (approx. 12-14cookies)
Amaretto Cookie
Minimum Order 1/2 lb. (approx. 8-10)
Anginetti - Italian Lemon Cookies
The Anginetti cookie is a very traditional Italian Lemon cookie that offers just the right sweetness and lemon flavor. Somewhat of a crunchy cookie with its lemon-glaze, you will surely love each bite!
Minimum Order 1/2 lb. (approx. 10-12 cookies)
Anisette Cookies ("Pasticcini d' Anice")
A delicate Italian butter cookie that is complimented by Anise flavoring and centered with a small bit of candied cherry.
Minimum order 1/2 lb. (approx. 14-15 cookies)
Anise Chocolate Chip Cookies (Gluten-Free)
Minimum Order 1 Dozen *****Gluten-Free*****
“Bistotŏ”
The Bistotŏ is a melt-in-your-mouth double chocolate walnut cookie that is filled with walnuts and lots of chocolatey flavor and then topped off with chocolate sprinkles. Truly a one-of-a-kind cookie that is sure to please your taste buds!
Minimum Order 1/2 lb. (approx. 9-10)
Black and White Hearts ("Cuoricini")
A melt-in-your-Mouth buttery cookie with just a hint of orange flavor and then half is dipped in delicious chocolate! You simply can't eat just one!
Minimum order: 1/2 lb. (approx. 7-9)
"Boschetti" Chocolate Drizzle Walnut Cookies
Minimum Order of 1 dozen
Buckeye Delights
A delicious chocolate brownie-like base with a peanut butter center and then topped with a dark chocolate icing!
Minimum order: 12 Count (approx. 1.lb)
Italian Butter Cookies ("Pasticcini al Burro")
Soft and delightful cookies that come in a variety of shapes. Some are colored and some are topped with sprinkles. Shown here are Annabelle's colored and chocolate Italian butter cookies.
Minimum order: 1 lb.
When ordering, please specify if you would like them plain with sprinkles or colored, or chocolate. If no specification is made, then Annabelle reserves the right to make your selection for you!
Cappuccino Cookies
These are soft and delicious cookies for those who simply love a good "Cappuccino" with every bite! White chocolate and dark chocolate chips throughout make this cookie melt in your mouth.
Minimum Order 1/2 lb (approx. 9-10)
"Dolce di Cedro" Lime Cookies
Lime Cookies that simply burst with citrus flavor! With a light dusting of powder sugar, you won't be able to put these down!
Minimum Order 1/2 lb. (approx. 18-20)
Chocolate Almond Fingers ("Diti di cioccolato e mandorla" caratteristici)
These are soft Almond flavored cookies that are crisp on the outside and tender on the inside and then filled with chocolate and topped with sliced Almonds.
Great with coffee!
Minimum order: 1lb. (approx. 18-21)
Chocolate-Almond Drops (Sugar-Free and Organic)
Minimum order of 1 dozen
Chocolate Chip & Double Chocolate Chip Cookies
Soft and chewy Chocolate Chip and Double Chocolate Chip Cookies (Made with Ghirardelli chocolate). Absolutely the best Chocolate Chip Cookies you will ever taste!!!!
Minimum order: 1 lb. (approx. 18-20 cookies)
When ordering Double Chocolate chip, please be sure to click the "Add to Cart" button below.
Double Chocolate Chip -- Minimum Order: 2 Dozen
“Cioccolato Frutta Pasticcini” (Chocolate Fruit Cookies)
These fruity chocolate cookies are almost like eating a chocolate fruit cake. Absolutely yummy!
Minimum order: 1 lb. (approx. 16-18)
Chocolate Raisin Spice Cookies
A soft chocolatey raisin cookie that offers a surprising peppered bite. Topped with a chocolate icing and chocolate sprinkles. These will leave you wanting more!
Minimum Order - 1 lb. (approx. 17-18)
Cranberry Thumbprint Cookies
A soft thumbprint pecan-cookie base filled with a Cranberry Jam filling and then drizzled with white chocolate.
Minimum Order: 1/2 lb. (approx. 9-11)
**Cookies are seasonal - Please inquire if they are available before ordering"
Cremosini
A soft "creamy" kinda of cookie that is very similar to a Snickerdoodle. With a cinnamon and sugar topping, these cookies are truly one of a kind!
Minimum Order: 1/2 lb. (approx. 12-15)
Cucidati (Sicilian Fig Cookies)
The Cucidati (Sicilian Fig Cookies) are traditionally served at Christmas time, but can be enjoyed anytime of year! These luscious little pastries are filled with a delectable fig-paste blend that includes walnuts, dates, apricot, raisins and black raspberry brandy. Topped with either a chocolate drizzle or iced with sprinkles, the Cucidati is sure to please fig lovers!
Minimum order 1 lb.
"Dolci di Fichi" (Italian Fig Cookie)
A soft fig cookie that is filled with bits of rum-soaked figs and dates, and walnuts. With a hint of cloves and cinnamon, this cookie is absolutely delicious!
Minimum order 1 lb. (approx. 18-20)
"Nocellini" Chocolate-Hazelnut Cookie
An eggless cookie that simply melts in your mouth! Chocolate and Nutella lovers will surely delight with every bite!
Minimum Order 1 lb. (approx. 18-20)
Chocolate-Coffee Macaroons
Delicious Almond Chocolate Macaroons that are Coffee Flavored and have a chocolate chip center.
Minimum Order - 1lb (24-26 cookies)
Chocolate Shortbread Cookie (Sugar-Free and Vegan Friendly)
Minimum Order of 1 dozen.
Italian Coconut Cookies ("Pasticcini di Cocco")
These are cake-like cookies that have a nice coconut flavor to them and a hint of anise flavoring. Great to serve at tea parties or at Christmas or Easter time!!
Minimum order: 1 lb. (approx. 24-26)
Coconut Lemon Bliss Cookies ("Pasticcini di Limone e Cocco")
These chewy-lemony flavored cookies with the sweetness of coconut added to them are sure to be an absolute delight!
Minimum order 1/2 lb. (approx 9-10)
Coconut Cream Macaroons
Minimum Order 1 dozen
Annabelle's Signature Coconut Macaroons ("Amaretti di Cocco")
Annabelle's Signature Italian Coconut Macaroons are covered in white** and dark chocolate and are simply too hard to resist. For those who love the sweetness of coconut mixed with chocolate, you can't go wrong with Annabelle's Signature Italian Coconut Macaroons!
**Note, the white chocolate can be specially colored upon request.
Minimum Order: 1 lb. approx. 9-11)
Please specify when ordering by sending a messageif you prefer only white or dark chocolate, otherwise you will receive a combination of both.
Coddura Culou Italian Easter Cookies
Coddura Culou is typically a Sicilian Easter Bread shaped like an Easter Basket that is somewhat cookie like because of the added Almond Paste. A few years back, I had the idea to turn them into a cookie and they turned out great! I'm sure you will love them as much as my friends and family have!
Minimum order 1lb. (approx. 30-35)
This is a seasonal cookie and is not always available year-round! Please Inquire before ordering.
Date-Nut Surprise Cookies ("Datteri Gioia")
Soft and delicious spiced cookies with the "surprisingly" incredible date-nut filling that is out-of-this world!
Minimum order: 1lb. (approx. 18-21)
“Foglietti” (Green-Leaf) Mint Cookies
Butter Cookies shaped into a leaf and then filled with a creamy chocolate mint filling.
Other colors are available. Please email Annabelle to inquire about other colors. Please note that these cookies are approximately 2" in length.
Minimum order: 1lb. (approx. 19-20)
Iced Italian Cookies (a.k.a. "Italian Love Knots")
Delicious and somewhat crunchy cookie that is filled with Anisette flavor. Iced and sprinkled. Anise lovers will not just stop at one!
Minimum order 1/2 lb (approx. 8-9)
"Limoneo" Lemon Sandwich Cookies
Annabelle's Limoneo are delectable little lemony treats. Two cookies sandwiched together with a creamy lemon filling and then dusted with powdered sugar.
Minimum Order - 1 lb. (approx. 16-20)
Neapolitan Cookies
One part chocolate, one part almond, and one part cherry, Annabelle's Neapolitan cookies are truly delicious!
Minimum Order - 1/2 lb. (approx. 9-11)
Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
Soft and chewy oatmeal raisin cookies that are packed with raisins and have just a hint of cinnamon and maple. Truly a unique twist to your traditional oatmeal raisin cookie. You never will want any other!
Minimum order: 1 lb. (approx. 20-22)
Orange Poppy Seed Cookies
A soft cookie that is flavored with fresh orange zest and poppy seeds.
Minimum Order: 1/2 lb. (approx. 10-11)
Orange Zest Sugar Cookies ("Pasticinni All' Arancio")
These Orange Zest Sugar cookies simply melt in your melt just like a creamsicle.
Minimum Order: 1/2 lb. (approx. 16-18)
Peanut Butter Blossoms - Gluten-Free
These delicious Peanut Butter Blossoms are filled with peanutty goodness and then topped with two mini Hershey's kisses. Best of all, these cookies are ****GLUTEN-FREE!
Minimum order: 1lb. (approx. 16-18)
"Raggio Di Sole” (Ray of Sunshine) Lemon Cookies
These lemony cookies are like a ray of sunshine in your mouth as they burst with citrus flavor! Chewy with just a slight crunch on the outside from the sanding sugar. Lemon lovers won't be able to put these down!
Minimum Order: 1 lb. (approx. 17-19)
Rainbow Sugar Cookies ("Arcobaleni")
Blue, Green, Purple, Orange and yellow Rainbow sugar cookies. Children light up when they bite into these. Each colored cookie tastes just like the color that it represents! Yummy!
Minimum order: 1 lb. (approx. 19-22)
Red Velvet Cookies
These devilishly rich cookies are sure to please! A light and cakey cookie that has just the right amount "crunch" to it with the sprinkles on top!
Minimum Order: 1 lb. (approx. 23-26)
Regina Italian Cookies
The Regina Italian Sesame Cookie is another very traditional Italian cookie that was born in the region of Sicily. Named “Regina” (queen) in honor of Regina Margherita di Savoia who was the second and much beloved queen of a United Italy, it is similar to the Sicilian Sesame Seed Cookie in texture. However, the Regina cookie provides you with delicious vanilla flavoring throughout, versus the Anise/Orange flavor of the Sicilian Sesame Seed Cookie. It is also finger shaped. Crunchy on the outside, but slightly softer in the middle, these Italian Regina cookies are sure to delight you with each bite!
Minimum order of 1lb. - (approx. 20-22) ****Can be made Gluten-Free
Ricotta Cheese Cookies
A delicious soft cookie that is made with ricotta cheese and provides hint of orange. You definitely won't eat just one!
Minimum Order: 1lb. (aprox. 18-19)
S'Mores Cookies
These cookies are just what you would think of when you think of the chocolatey goodness of S'mores, but better! Bits of marshmallow mixed with chocolate chips in a brown-sugar base! Yum!
Minimum Order: (approx. 17-20)
"Sposini" -- Raspberry-Chocolate Presses (Lampone-cioccolato)
These delicious butter cookies are filled with Raspberry jam then pressed and "cemented" together with Chocolate and then dipped in sprinkles. You definitely can't eat just one of these!
Minimum order: 1lb. (approx. 22-24)
"Sposini" Pineapple Presses (Ananas)
Tantalizing butter cookies that are filled with Pineapple preserves and then pressed together with Chocolate and then dipped in chocolate jimmies.
Minimum order: 1lb. (approx. 22-24)
Sicilian Sesame Seed Cookies
Sicilian Sesame Seed Cookies are one of those traditional Italian treats that seem to tickle the taste buds with just a slight hint of anise and orange flavoring. Annabelle's tasty, toasty and crunchy sesame seed cookies are sure to bring back memories!
Minimum order 1 lb. (approx. 20-22)
Italian Thumb Print Cookies
You have never tasted such a delicious thumb-print cookie! A thick buttery sugar cookie that is sure to tantalize your taste-buds with each bite. Filled with pineapple, blackberry and raspberry jams and then drizzled with white chocolate.
Minimum order: 1 lb. (19-20)
Sicilian TuTu Cookies (TOTÕ)
A cake-like chocolate cookie that is flavored with coffee, cinnamon, and walnuts, and then topped with a rich chocolate frosting.
Can be made with or without Coffee flavor. Please specify if you would like yours without.
Minimum Order: 1 lb. (approx. 15-18)
Venetian Layer Cookies
Also known as the 7-layered cookie and Rainbow Cookie, everyone will certainly go crazy for these soft delicious Italian treats! New Yorkers especially, love these delectable multi-colored cookies. Three layers of very soft moist cake flavored with almond paste that are then sandwiched together with an apricot and raspberry fillings and topped with a dark chocolate ganache. (Approx. cut into 1" x 1" squares).
Minimum order of 1 lb. (approx. 16 - 20 cookies)
"Verdacchio" Pistachio-Cherry Cookies
A melt-in-your-mouth cookie that is bursting with Pistachio flavor and bits of cherry throughout. Pistachio lovers won't be able to eat just one!
Minimum Order: 1/2 lb. (approx.14-16)
Wedding Butter Cookies ("Pasticcini di Sposalizio")
A melt-in-your-mouth butter cookie that is filled with a special blend of crushed pecans, almonds, and walnuts and then rolled in powder sugar.
Minimum Order: 1/2 lb. (approx. 8-10)
Cappuccino Truffles
Minimum Order 2 dozen ****Gluten-Free
Cherry Bombs ("Bombe-Ciliegia")
Minimum order of 2 dozen only.
Pina Colada Balls (Palline "Pina Colado" Caratteristici)
Minimum order of 2 dozen only.
Raspberry Truffles
Minimum order 2 Dozen
Rum/Amaretto (Palline al Rum/Amerretto")
Minimum Order 2 dozen
Whiskey Raspberry Cake Truffles
Minimum Order of 2 dozen
